Compare communities without hiding the gaps

What does this comparison show?

Compare the same fields across public 55+ community profiles, including association costs, age descriptions, housing, golf, pets, and source dates. Missing, disputed, or outdated details remain visible and are never treated as $0. Sources Checked identifies automated source verification with editor escalation; it is not legal certification. Confirm current charges and governing rules directly.

Your comparison

Select two to five communities. Their order here becomes their A–E identity throughout the comparison.

2 / 5

2 communities selected. You can add 3 more.

  1. Colony CoveEllenton, FL 34222 · North Port–Bradenton–Sarasota
  2. Bay IndiesVenice, FL 34285 · North Port–Bradenton–Sarasota

Comparing 2 communities

This is a tradeoff view, not a ranking. A field that no source publishes stays unresolved instead of counting in anyone’s favor.

  1. Colony CoveEllenton, FL 34222
  2. Bay IndiesVenice, FL 34285

Biggest differences

  • Current published price
    Colony Cove
    Operator sale-inventory snapshot: $11,000 to $246,000
    Bay Indies
    Operator sale-inventory snapshot: $20,400 to $220,900
  • Separate recurring charges
    Colony Cove
    Voluntary CCHOA membership dues: $20 per household per year, or $35 for 2 years, per the resident homeowners association FAQ
    Bay Indies
    No separate recurring charge verified
  • Published age policy
    Colony Cove
    Operator markets Colony Cove as an age-qualified 55+ community; third-party profile corroborates the 55+ restriction
    Bay Indies
    Operator markets Bay Indies as an age-qualified 55+ community; third-party profiles corroborate a 55+ age restriction
  • Housing
    Colony Cove
    Manufactured homes on leased land under Florida Chapter 723
    Bay Indies
    Manufactured homes offered for sale or rent

Side-by-side details

Missing, disputed, and outdated values remain visible and are never treated as zero. Open a profile to review its field status and sources.

Focus the table16 of 16 details shown
  1. Colony Cove
  2. Bay Indies
Community details arranged by field. Scroll horizontally to review every selected community.
Community detail
Colony CoveEllenton, FL 34222
Bay IndiesVenice, FL 34285
HOA / POACheck neededLot rent, association charges, and inclusions not publicly verifiedLot rent, association charges, and inclusions not publicly verified
GolfCheck neededGolf charges and requirements not publicly verifiedOperator lists an on-site driving range; no golf course or golf charges are published
Rental policyCheck neededOwner rental policy not publicly verifiedOwner rental policy not publicly verified
Guest policyCheck neededAssociation FAQ publishes guest registration with management, ID card and wristband issuance, and a no-overnight-street-parking ruleGuest policy not publicly verified
Document statusPublic profile; sources not yet checkedPublic profile; sources not yet checked
LocationEllenton, FL 34222Venice, FL 34285
Community typemanufactured homemanufactured home
Current sales / inventoryCurrent sales and inventory status not yet verifiedCurrent sales and inventory status not yet verified
Current published priceOperator sale-inventory snapshot: $11,000 to $246,000Operator sale-inventory snapshot: $20,400 to $220,900
Separate recurring chargesVoluntary CCHOA membership dues: $20 per household per year, or $35 for 2 years, per the resident homeowners association FAQNo separate recurring charge verified
Published age policyOperator markets Colony Cove as an age-qualified 55+ community; third-party profile corroborates the 55+ restrictionOperator markets Bay Indies as an age-qualified 55+ community; third-party profiles corroborate a 55+ age restriction
HousingManufactured homes on leased land under Florida Chapter 723Manufactured homes offered for sale or rent
Pet policyOperator lists pets allowed with two dog parks; third-party profile reports a 75-pound weight limit and breed restrictionsOperator lists pets allowed; third-party profile reports a two-pet, 45-pound limit
Amenities in cited sourcesFive clubhouses, Six heated swimming pools, Two fitness centers, Pickleball courts, Tennis courts, Shuffleboard, Two dog parks, Marina and boat dock, Fishing, Woodworking shop, Library, Game room, Billiards, Banquet room, Picnic area, Laundry facilities, Community activitiesThree swimming pools, Spa or hot tub, Sauna, Fitness center, Clubhouse, Tennis courts, Pickleball, Bocce ball, Shuffleboard, Horseshoes, Driving range, 3-mile walking and biking path, Waterfront sites, Game room, Billiards, Picnic area, Laundry facilities, Community activities
Cited sources8 sources7 sources
Last verified2026-08-122026-08-12

HOA / POACheck needed

  • Colony Cove
    Lot rent, association charges, and inclusions not publicly verified
  • Bay Indies
    Lot rent, association charges, and inclusions not publicly verified

GolfCheck needed

  • Colony Cove
    Golf charges and requirements not publicly verified
  • Bay Indies
    Operator lists an on-site driving range; no golf course or golf charges are published

Rental policyCheck needed

  • Colony Cove
    Owner rental policy not publicly verified
  • Bay Indies
    Owner rental policy not publicly verified

Guest policyCheck needed

  • Colony Cove
    Association FAQ publishes guest registration with management, ID card and wristband issuance, and a no-overnight-street-parking rule
  • Bay Indies
    Guest policy not publicly verified

Document status

Location

Community type

Current sales / inventory

  • Colony Cove
    Current sales and inventory status not yet verified
  • Bay Indies
    Current sales and inventory status not yet verified

Current published price

  • Colony Cove
    Operator sale-inventory snapshot: $11,000 to $246,000
  • Bay Indies
    Operator sale-inventory snapshot: $20,400 to $220,900

Separate recurring charges

  • Colony Cove
    Voluntary CCHOA membership dues: $20 per household per year, or $35 for 2 years, per the resident homeowners association FAQ
  • Bay Indies
    No separate recurring charge verified

Published age policy

  • Colony Cove
    Operator markets Colony Cove as an age-qualified 55+ community; third-party profile corroborates the 55+ restriction
  • Bay Indies
    Operator markets Bay Indies as an age-qualified 55+ community; third-party profiles corroborate a 55+ age restriction

Housing

  • Colony Cove
    Manufactured homes on leased land under Florida Chapter 723
  • Bay Indies
    Manufactured homes offered for sale or rent

Pet policy

  • Colony Cove
    Operator lists pets allowed with two dog parks; third-party profile reports a 75-pound weight limit and breed restrictions
  • Bay Indies
    Operator lists pets allowed; third-party profile reports a two-pet, 45-pound limit

Amenities in cited sources

  • Colony Cove
    Five clubhouses, Six heated swimming pools, Two fitness centers, Pickleball courts, Tennis courts, Shuffleboard, Two dog parks, Marina and boat dock, Fishing, Woodworking shop, Library, Game room, Billiards, Banquet room, Picnic area, Laundry facilities, Community activities
  • Bay Indies
    Three swimming pools, Spa or hot tub, Sauna, Fitness center, Clubhouse, Tennis courts, Pickleball, Bocce ball, Shuffleboard, Horseshoes, Driving range, 3-mile walking and biking path, Waterfront sites, Game room, Billiards, Picnic area, Laundry facilities, Community activities

Cited sources

Last verified

Evidence-triggered email

Email me this comparison

We send a link to this comparison with today's sourced values and dates, then one note if any of these profiles change. Nothing else.

Saved shortlist…

Saved communities stay on this device. Add any of them to the current comparison, or remove them from the shortlist.

Loading your saved shortlist…

Find communities to add

Search by community, city, market, state, builder, or ZIP code. Filter by market or city when you want a tighter list.

127 communities found · showing the first 12.

Davenport, FL · Orlando–Kissimmee–Sanford

St. Cloud, FL · Orlando–Kissimmee–Sanford

Groveland, FL · Orlando–Kissimmee–Sanford

  • Trilogy OrlandoGroveland, FL 34736 · Community profile

Kissimmee, FL · Orlando–Kissimmee–Sanford

Land O’ Lakes, FL · Tampa–St. Petersburg–Clearwater

  • Del Webb BexleyLand O’ Lakes, FL 34638 · Community profile

Wimauma, FL · Tampa–St. Petersburg–Clearwater

North Port, FL · North Port–Bradenton–Sarasota

  • Cypress FallsNorth Port, FL 34289 · Community profile

Lakewood Ranch, FL · North Port–Bradenton–Sarasota

Parrish, FL · North Port–Bradenton–Sarasota

Privacy choices

Necessary site functions are always available. Optional analytics are controlled separately.

Optional analytics